..Says Removing Constitutional Right Requires National Referendum..
Montserrado County Senator Abraham Darius Dillon has disagreed with the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Liberia Yamie Quiqui Gbeisay over a proposal to abolish trial by jury, arguing that the constitutional guarantee cannot be removed through legislative action but would require a national referendum.
Senator Dillon, in a statement addressing the Chief Justice, maintained that the right to trial by jury is protected under Article 20(a) of the 1986 Constitution of Liberia and should not be abolished simply because of challenges associated with its implementation.
According to the Senator, any attempt to eliminate the constitutional right must follow the constitutionally prescribed process for constitutional amendment, which he argues would require a national referendum.
Sen. Dillon further questioned whether concerns about jury tampering, cited by the Chief Justice as a reason for suggesting the abolition of jury trials, provide sufficient justification for such a far-reaching constitutional change.
โBy suggesting that โjury-tamperingโ hurts the intent and purpose for โtrial by juryโ, for which you are seeking โdissolutionโ thereof, is simply exposing the weakness of our justice system and failure of the judiciary to decisively punish alleged doers of the act to serve as deterrent,โ Dillon stated.
The Senator argued that problems associated with jury tampering should prompt stronger enforcement of existing laws rather than the elimination of a constitutional safeguard.
He maintained that the inability to effectively prevent or punish misconduct should not become a basis for abandoning a fundamental right guaranteed by the countryโs supreme law.
โWe cannot simply seek to undo laws because of our failure to summon the courage to implement and enforce the laws,โ Dillon emphasized.
Dillon believes that the constitutional right must be preserved unless the constitutionally established amendment process is followed.
โI disagree with your suggestion to โdissolveโ the fundamental right to trial by jury guaranteed by the 1986 Constitution,โ the Senator declared.